Baha'u'llah began this Tablet by telling us the source of all good, and where that good could lead. He told us what constitutes wisdom and religion, and where true glory, love and remembrance can be found. He explained the importance of relying upon God, detaching ourselves from the things of this world, and developing our understanding. He then turned to the source of courage and power, the essence of charity, faith and safety. From there, He explored the beginnings of magnanimity and the true essence of wealth, before mirroring the beginning by identifying the source of all evil and the consequences of turning away from God
He continues that latest theme with the following:
The most burning fire is to question the signs of God, to dispute idly that which He hath revealed, to deny Him and carry one’s self proudly before Him.
If the source of all evil is to turn away from God and focus on those ungodly things in life, how does this paragraph follow?
We often think of "the most burning fire" as hell, especially in terms of Christian mythology, and that place described by Dante in his Inferno. But we know from the Writings that heaven and hell are "conditions within our own being", not some external place. So it would appear that this "burning fire" is something that is within. At the very least it is something that we feel within.
It's interesting, though, isn't it? He describes this fire not as something that we have to endure, such as walking across hot coals, but as a series of actions. And while I first thought of them as separate things, it occurred to me that they may be related, if not even a path. I guess that this shouldn't really surprise me, for it seems that everything within this Tablet is all about action.
Here it begins with questioning the signs of God, continues to idle disputes, resulting in both denial and pride.
I suspect, though, that this doesn't mean that questioning in and of itself is wrong. After all, we are encouraged to engage in an independent investigation of truth, and doesn't this often require questioning? It probably has to do with the type of questioning that is being done. Some questions are asked to elicit information, others clarity, while some are designed to cast doubt, or even evoke anger. Here He specifically refers to questioning the "signs of God". But what are those signs?
Signs of God do not have to be limited to miracles. They can include the evidence of God's attributes in creation, the teachings of His Manifestations, or even the various qualities we encounter in other people.
I remember one time, I think I was around 14 or so, I was walking on the beach with a friend. It was a dreary day, a bit chill, but invigorating rather than uncomfortable. We got to talking about God, and she said she didn't believe in God. I asked her why, because I was genuinely curious. She said that she had never seen a sign from Him. I said, "Well, have you asked?" She then stopped and cried out, "God, if you're there, give me a sign." And I swear, as soon as she said this the clouds parted just a little and a ray of sunlight shone upon the water. A flock of ducks lifted up, the droplets falling from their wings, sparkling like diamonds in the light. It was an amazing sight to behold. And my friend said, "See? Nothing."
To me that was such a clear sign of God, and I have carried the memory of that day with me ever since. Oh, and not as a condemnation of my friend. Not at all. Just as a reminder that we all look at the world through different eyes.
Was she wrong in questioning? I don't think so. And can I blame her for not noticing? Nope. In this case I don't think she was questioning a sign of God. She just didn't notice it.
But if she had noticed it and then questioned it? That would be a totally different story. It would be like all those stories of people who had met Baha'u'llah and asked for a sign, but then moved the goalpost after the sign was given.
My favourite example is from Varqa, the poet and martyr. He was listening to Baha'u'llah speak when he silently wished for a sign of His station. He recalled a particular verse from the Qur'an and almost immediately Baha'u'llah incorporated that verse into His talk. Varqa then wondered whether it might merely have been a coincidence, at which point Baha'u'llah suddenly turned towards him and exclaimed, "Wasn't this sufficient proof for you?"
If we ask for evidence, we should be prepared to recognize it when it comes. We can certainly examine what we've witnessed, but if we continually move the goalposts whenever something challenges our assumptions, are we really looking for truth?
The next step on that path is to "dispute idly", which, again, is not the same as sincere questioning. I think there's a big difference between asking a question because we want to understand something and arguing about it because we don't want to accept it. There's also a big difference between deciding what the sign ought to look like and failing to recognize what is already before us, but that's probably an entire article unto itself.
If we do continue down that path, though, it does seem like it would lead to denial. And I have seen many people deny God, and wax proud in their denial. Mind you, I've also met many humble atheists who very reasonably deny the various definitions of God they've encountered. I'm not talking about them, for even Baha'u'llah said, "Whoso claimeth to have known Thee hath, by virtue of such a claim, testified to his own ignorance..." So how can I fault anyone for not believing?
But to wax proud about it? That is a form of egotism that I just don't understand.
Why would that be the "most burning fire"? I'm not sure. Really, I'm not. But I can imagine that being shown proof after proof, and denying every single one of them over and over, would probably lead to frustration, and yes, even anger against those who do believe. And that anger, growing with every new sign that is shown, or every new believer who is satisfied, would, I suppose, be like a burning fire that one cannot escape.
Again, all of this comes down to one's own actions. This fire does not seem to something that is imposed upon us, but rather is the result of our own perspective.
