Friday, November 20, 2026

But Seriously Folks...

Why do so many people think that being spiritual means being emotionless?

I remember as a kid watching Charlton Heston in The Ten Commandments. He was a relatively normal person up until the scene with the Burning Bush. After that, it was as if all emotions had lobotomized from him. There was no anger, no fury, no love, nothing. Just a blank stare as he recited the line, "Let my people go."

I see something similar in many prayer gatherings. People bounce in, filled with joy and enthusiasm at greeting old friends. But then, as soon as we are called to sit and pray, it seems as if all emotions are wiped away. And I'm guilty of this, too!

I will say, though, that this is not what I see with a group of friends of mine from Africa. Prayer, for them, includes laughter and dance. Their prayers, from what I can tell, include one person practically singing the words, while those around clap in what feels to me like encouragement. It is as if it's not really prayer if you're quiet and still.

Ruhiyyih Khanum said that we should take the Faith seriously, but never ourselves. I've always liked that line. In fact, the ability to laugh at ourselves might be one of the better protections against spiritual pride. There's something rather healthy about being able to recognise our own absurdities. I think there's a big difference between laughing at something sacred, and laughing at our own attempt to be sacred. Those are two very different things. The ego can be remarkably pompous, and humour has a way of puncturing that.

Even the House of Justice wrote, "Humour, happiness, joy are characteristics of a true Bahá'í life." They pointed out that "true happiness and joy and humour... are parts of a balanced life that includes serious thought, compassion and humble servitude to God, are characteristics that enrich life and add to its radiance." In other words, spirituality does not preclude humour and joy. They are a part of it.

It's all about balance, though, isn't it? Society continues to try and find ways to distract us, amuse us, grab our attention and not let it go. But that always leads to boredom, and the quest for ever greater distraction. This is one of the reasons why movies have become more extreme, modern novels almost always include a torrid sex scene, and even the "news" has become more and more sensational. It is all an attempt to try and grab our attention amidst the greater increase in volume around us.

But back to that prayer gathering.

Why do we, and here I really mean "I", feel the need to show a sense of solemnity when getting ready to pray?

Speaking only for myself, I know that I'm an introvert. And yes, I know that so many who have met me will find that hard to believe, but it's true. It doesn't mean that I shun people, or prefer to be alone. I don't. But when I'm tired, I get my recharge by being more solitary. Interacting with people is actually quite exhausting for me. I love it, but I'm drained afterwards. In fact, if you ever have the chance to watch me address an audience, you may note that I'm actually talking to only one or two people. Oh, sure, my eyes roam, but that's just training. My real focus is only on a couple of people because I can't focus on more than that at a time.

I've also noticed that when I'm on Pilgrimage, and anywhere near the Shrine of the Bab, my very strong inclination is to ignore everyone around me. I feel so pulled to the Shrine that it's like I don't have any extra energy to spare to pay attention to those around me. I actually apologized to my family for that when we were there.

Maybe that's one of the reasons why I, at least, tend to be more somber when praying.

But honestly, when I'm praying on my own? I'm smiling a lot more. I'm giggling. Yes, giggling. I'm just so happy to be present that I can't help myself.

Shortly after we got married, my wife and I were just lying on our bed holding hands. There was nothing going on. We were tired, and just sort of collapsed there. As we lay there, our hands found each other and our fingers intertwined. And so we just lay there, holding each other's hand. It was at that moment that I had this sudden realization that I was happy. I mean, really happy. Not just content, but deeply and fully happy. I was so happy that I started to smile. And that was when it hit. I was so happy that I was actually smiling. That's a lot of joy in there to force its way out into a smile.

When I realized that I was smiling uncontrollably that made me even more happy. I mean, can you imagine being so happy that you can't help but smile? Ok, that made me even more happy. So happy, in fact, that I started to laugh at the sheer wonder of being overwhelmingly happy.

Now, I have to confess something here. When I laugh, and I mean when I naturally laugh, it is absolutely silent. I don't naturally laugh out loud. I've actually trained myself to do so as a courtesy to those around me, but no. When I'm alone, my laughter is quiet and internal.

So there we were, lying down holding hands, and I began laughing. Not the forced laughter that is aloud, but my truly natural quiet laugh. And that was when I realized that I was so happy that I was actually laughing. Which filled me with even more joy, which made me laugh even more, which made me even more joyous, which made me... Oh, you get the idea. It was the most wonderful feedback loop I've ever experienced.

My wife, however, did not know any of this.

From her perspective, we were both exhausted, collapsed on the bed, and just held hands. It was sweet.

Then, again from her perspective, I suddenly began to shake. My chest seemed to be suddenly quivering, and it was as if my whole body was bouncing, just a little, up and down.

She began to wonder if I was epileptic and had failed to warn her.

She even asked me, quite concerned, if she needed to call an ambulance.

Which I found hilarious.

Which made me laugh even harder. Still silent, though.

Which got her even more concerned, to the point where I think she sat up, anxious. I honestly can't recall, but it seems like the sort of thing she would have done.

Finally I was able to catch my breath just enough to gasp out, "I'm laughing."

Which really puzzled her. She honestly thought I was having some sort of seizure.

But no, she eventually understood, and I'm sure she wondered what sort of lunatic she had gotten saddled with.

And I have to say, that's not the only time that's happened to me. I've done exactly the same thing when praying. Oh, not with anyone else around, but yes, while praying. And it's wonderful. To be so filled with joy that you can't help but quiver with laughter? What more can one ask for in prayer?

Perhaps we've been taught to associate prayer with solemnity because we think that reverence requires it. But I wonder whether we've got things backwards. Maybe the greatest reverence sometimes comes from being so happy to be in God's presence that we simply can't contain ourselves.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Words of Wisdom, part 7

In part 6 of this series looking at Baha'u'llah's Words of Wisdom, we discussed the danger of becoming so attached to what we think we know that we stop being willing to learn. Moving on, the next passage, or paragraph, or sentence, or whichever term you prefer, is:

The source of error is to disbelieve in the One true God, rely upon aught else but Him, and flee from His Decree.

A few things immediately jump to mind. First, this follows not only "the source of all learning", but also that "essence of abasement". Again, the simplicity and profundity of the path He is laying out for us astonishes me. It is so well structured that it amazes me it took me this long to notice. Not that it's a big surprise. It's just a surprise that it took me so long to notice.

Second, the issue is not just disbelieving. The problem is to rely on other things, and perhaps more importantly, it is to flee. That is the most active verb in the whole passage. Over and over throughout this Tablet what has really struck me is the awareness that our ignorance or blindness are never really the issue. The real issue is something that we actively do, or fail to do.

Disbelieving is just an intellectual issue. Relying on something is a question of where we place our confidence. But fleeing suggests that we're running away from something. And that raises the question of what we're running away from, and why. In this case it's God's decree, yes, but probably the implications of accepting it.

I know that I actually delayed my own declaration merely because I enjoyed drinking dark ale. Seriously. That was pretty much it. I mean, yeah, to those who have been reading my blog for a long time or have read the book Twigs of a Family Tree, yes there were other issues, but I honestly think that simple implication of declaring was enough to prevent me from considering it for some time.

All this to say that this is the source of error, not necessarily every single error we will ever make. Just like the "source of learning" from the previous article, this one, too, can sometimes meander and wander around until it ends up far from the original source, even to the point that we may not recognize it. And that's ok. I won't try to dispute that. Instead, I will just say that when we have the opportunity to respond, the direction we choose matters. We can seek, investigate, trust and learn, or we can turn away, substitute and flee. And that brings us right back to the Manifestations as Educators. They don't simply give us information. They show us a direction in which to travel.

But if we choose to rely on something other than God? If we choose to flee?

True loss is for him whose days have been spent in utter ignorance of his self.

You may recall those articles I wrote about the Epistle to the Son of the Wolf a few months back. That volume began with a series of paragraphs that I lovingly summarize as "asking him to get down on his knees and beg forgiveness". I had long wondered about them. I mean, if I were to write to someone like him, with any possible hope of having him read it, I sure wouldn't start off with that strong of a heavy-handed condemnation.  Oh, and that's not a criticism of Baha'u'llah. Not at all. It's a statement that my vision is nowhere near as keen as His.

But here, Baha'u'llah has explained in a single sentence for me. He was ensuring that, before anything else, the Son of the Wolf knew who he was. Well, I say before anything else, but of course the praise and acknowledgement of God comes first. But before anything else aside from that.

But why would this be "True loss"? As usual, I don't really know. After all, these are just my own personal musings, nothing official, so you can take them or leave as you wish. But to me, if you don't know where you are, how can you know where you're going?

The Kitab-i-Iqan began with us wanting to "attain the shores of the ocean of true understanding". And I said over and over in my comments on that volume, if we want to help guide someone to the "shores of the ocean", we first have to know where they are. I mean, think about it on a practical level. If I were to phone you up and ask you how I can get to the ocean, don't you need to know where I am? You can't just tell me to go left, or forward 500 metres. You'd only be guessing. But if you knew exactly where I was, and which direction I was facing, then you could very confidently direct me.

And the same is true as an individual. If I don't know myself, where I am spiritually, how can I know in which direction I need to advance along my own spiritual path?

Knowing ourselves might also mean recognizing our motives, our attachments, our assumptions and the ways we deceive ourselves. When it comes to my dark ale story, I knew what I wanted, but hadn't fully acknowledged how much that desire was influencing my decision. Sometimes knowing ourselves means discovering that the explanation we've been giving ourselves isn't quite the whole story. And that brings us back to the previous article. The insistent self can be remarkably good at protecting its own comfortable version of reality.

Knowing ourselves, our virtues, our strengths, and our flaws, is always the starting point. And maybe that's also why the Short Obligatory Prayer begins with such simple statements about our own reality. But that's another story altogether.

For now, this Tablet ends with:

The essence of all that We have revealed for thee is Justice, is for man to free himself from idle fancy and imitation, discern with the eye of oneness His glorious handiwork, and look into all things with a searching eye.

Thus have We instructed thee, manifested unto thee Words of Wisdom, that thou mayest be thankful unto the Lord, thy God, and glory therein amidst all peoples.

When I consider that "justice" is founded upon the pillars of "reward and punishment", this makes a lot more sense. We are rewarded for our good actions, and punished for our bad ones. But these are not handed down to us like a monetary fine in a court of law. They are the very natural result of our own actions. After all, if we don't free ourselves from "idle fancy and imitation", then all we are doing is walking blindly through life. If we fail to "discern with the eye of oneness His glorious handiwork", then we are missing out on so much beauty and wonder in the world. And if we don't "look into all things with a searching eye", then we will not only wander blindly, but in ignorance, too. Of course, this is just one aspect of justice, and He writes so much more about it, and its implications elsewhere. I just don't want to make this a dissertation about justice, so I'll leave it here for now.

And come to think of it, we can read that penultimate paragraph in another way, too. "The essence of all that We have revealed thee... is for man to free himself from idle fancy..." and so forth. Again, as I have said over and over, so much of the Iqan, and the Epistle to the Son of the Wolf, and many of the other Writings, do not seem to be overly concerned with imparting information. These all seem to be far more concerned with helping us learn how to explore the world around us, how to free ourselves from blindly following traditions, how to better recognize the glories of creation, and how to more effectively search for truth.

In this single paragraph, Baha'u'llah has summed it up so succinctly. First, free yourself from idle fancy and imitation. That's about freeing the mind from inherited assumptions and unexamined beliefs. Second, discern God's handiwork with the eye of oneness. That's about learning to see relationships and unity in creation. Third, look into all things with a searching eye. That's about continuing to investigate rather than assuming we've already understood everything. In other words, the passage seems to move from freeing ourselves, to learning to see, to continuing to investigate.

And for all that He has shown me in this short Tablet, yeah, I really am "thankful unto the Lord".

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Words of Wisdom, part 6

Whew. This is getting to be a lot longer than I expected when I first began looking at this relatively short text. In the last article we looked at what "the most burning fire" is, namely questioning the signs of God, idle disputation about what He has revealed, denying Him, and carrying oneself proudly before Him.

Again, whew.

From this point He goes on and informs us of the "source of all learning". Another example of where it comes from, not a definition, which is fine. No problem there for me. But where does this learning originate? From "the knowledge of God", which "cannot be attained save through knowledge of His Divine Manifestation".

Ok, this is another one of those passages where I really have to stop and ponder not only on what it says, but what it doesn't say. First of all, it does not say that you cannot have any knowledge unless you know or recognize the Manifestation. It says that any knowledge you do have can be traced back to this source. It's sort of like a river that arises from a spring. Further down the way you may have no knowledge of this spring. You cannot see it, or perhaps have no access to it. But if you were to trace it back, you would discover that point of origin.

Of course, this comes with some caveats. It does not mean that every fact, discovery, or detail of knowledge comes from Them. Rather that They are the source of the spiritual and intellectual foundations that make human education and civilization possible. As 'Abdu'l-Baha says, “The prophets of God are the first educators. They bestow universal education upon man and cause him to rise from lowest levels of savagery to the highest pinnacles of spiritual development.” They are not the only educators, just the first ones, without Whom all other educators would have no base on which to work.

"Knowledge", Baha'u'llah says, "is as wings to man's life, and a ladder for his ascent. Its acquisition is incumbent upon everyone.” But what happens when we don't acquire it? What happens when we are content with ignorance?

In the next passage, He writes:

The essence of abasement is to pass out from under the shadow of the Merciful and seek the shelter of the Evil One.

Here, my mind goes in an interesting direction. I often think about those people who fall prey to what they want to believe, ignoring all the evidence to the contrary. But let's be clear, simply not knowing something isn't necessarily a failing. None of us knows everything, and we all have gaps in our understanding. But there's a difference between not knowing and actively resisting the opportunity to know. The latter involves a choice. I think that's what He may be getting at when He describes the very active choice of seeking "the shelter of the Evil One".

Take the very real example of vaccines. Now, I know this can be contentious, but please, hear me out. 

There are legitimate reasons to question pharmaceutical companies. Whether it is their commercial interests, their pricing, their research practices or their accountability, there is no doubt that some have violated the trust we put in them. Likewise, questioning the safety or efficacy of a particular vaccine is not unreasonable. This is why there is so much testing that is required. The problem comes when someone takes legitimate concerns and turns them into a universal conclusion that no amount of evidence can change. This is when a legitimate concern becomes fanaticism. We've seen the consequences of such fanaticism in the resurgence of such preventable diseases as measles, to name but one example.

Baha'u'llah isn't telling us that people are merely turning away from the Merciful. He says that they are actively seeking shelter in something else. They aren't simply wandering away from that secure position, or failing to notice it. They are looking for security somewhere else. And maybe that security is found in the safety of their own belief, and the complacency of a group that agrees with them. Maybe they feel safe because they think they've found an explanation for everything, and nothing can disturb that. Any evidence that might help them is perceived as a threat. Ignorance may be uncomfortable, but false certainty can sure feel secure. As one person said, the problem with being wrong is that it feels like you're right.

Up above I asked what happens when we're content with ignorance. Now I think the real issue is being unwilling to acknowledge our ignorance. When we recognize our own ignorance we know to seek knowledge. But the person who feels like they already know it all doesn't even bother to look.

And maybe this brings us right back to the importance of the Manifestations as the true educators of humanity. Education requires a willingness to be educated. We have to recognize that there is something we don't yet understand.

Baha'u'llah has said that the "essence of abasement" is to "seek the shelter of the Evil One". 'Abdu'l-Baha has said that the true Satan is "the evil ego within us, not an evil personality outside.” He called it "The insistent self." And maybe that's the key here. I can easily see the problem being when we forsake the difficult path of educating ourselves, and instead "seek the shelter" of our own "insistent self". In other words, the problem isn't when we question education in the normal sense, but when we refuse to make ourselves teachable.

This, then, leads us to the very next passage, the source of error", but I think I'll tackle that one in the next article.


Monday, November 16, 2026

Words of Wisdom, part 5

Baha'u'llah began this Tablet by telling us the source of all good, and where that good could lead. He told us what constitutes wisdom and religion, and where true glory, love and remembrance can be found. He explained the importance of relying upon God, detaching ourselves from the things of this world, and developing our understanding. He then turned to the source of courage and power, the essence of charity, faith and safety. From there, He explored the beginnings of magnanimity and the true essence of wealth, before mirroring the beginning by identifying the source of all evil and the consequences of turning away from God

He continues that latest theme with the following:

The most burning fire is to question the signs of God, to dispute idly that which He hath revealed, to deny Him and carry one’s self proudly before Him.

If the source of all evil is to turn away from God and focus on those ungodly things in life, how does this paragraph follow?

We often think of "the most burning fire" as hell, especially in terms of Christian mythology, and that place described by Dante in his Inferno. But we know from the Writings that heaven and hell are "conditions within our own being", not some external place. So it would appear that this "burning fire" is something that is within. At the very least it is something that we feel within.

It's interesting, though, isn't it? He describes this fire not as something that we have to endure, such as walking across hot coals, but as a series of actions. And while I first thought of them as separate things, it occurred to me that they may be related, if not even a path. I guess that this shouldn't really surprise me, for it seems that everything within this Tablet is all about action.

Here it begins with questioning the signs of God, continues to idle disputes, resulting in both denial and pride.

I suspect, though, that this doesn't mean that questioning in and of itself is wrong. After all, we are encouraged to engage in an independent investigation of truth, and doesn't this often require questioning? It probably has to do with the type of questioning that is being done. Some questions are asked to elicit information, others clarity, while some are designed to cast doubt, or even evoke anger. Here He specifically refers to questioning the "signs of God". But what are those signs?

Signs of God do not have to be limited to miracles. They can include the evidence of God's attributes in creation, the teachings of His Manifestations, or even the various qualities we encounter in other people.

I remember one time, I think I was around 14 or so, I was walking on the beach with a friend. It was a dreary day, a bit chill, but invigorating rather than uncomfortable. We got to talking about God, and she said she didn't believe in God. I asked her why, because I was genuinely curious. She said that she had never seen a sign from Him. I said, "Well, have you asked?" She then stopped and cried out, "God, if you're there, give me a sign." And I swear, as soon as she said this the clouds parted just a little and a ray of sunlight shone upon the water. A flock of ducks lifted up, the droplets falling from their wings, sparkling like diamonds in the light. It was an amazing sight to behold. And my friend said, "See? Nothing."

To me that was such a clear sign of God, and I have carried the memory of that day with me ever since. Oh, and not as a condemnation of my friend. Not at all. Just as a reminder that we all look at the world through different eyes.

Was she wrong in questioning? I don't think so. And can I blame her for not noticing? Nope. In this case I don't think she was questioning a sign of God. She just didn't notice it.

But if she had noticed it and then questioned it? That would be a totally different story. It would be like all those stories of people who had met Baha'u'llah and asked for a sign, but then moved the goalpost after the sign was given.

My favourite example is from Varqa, the poet and martyr. He was listening to Baha'u'llah speak when he silently wished for a sign of His station. He recalled a particular verse from the Qur'an and almost immediately Baha'u'llah incorporated that verse into His talk. Varqa then wondered whether it might merely have been a coincidence, at which point Baha'u'llah suddenly turned towards him and exclaimed, "Wasn't this sufficient proof for you?"

If we ask for evidence, we should be prepared to recognize it when it comes. We can certainly examine what we've witnessed, but if we continually move the goalposts whenever something challenges our assumptions, are we really looking for truth?

The next step on that path is to "dispute idly", which, again, is not the same as sincere questioning. I think there's a big difference between asking a question because we want to understand something and arguing about it because we don't want to accept it. There's also a big difference between deciding what the sign ought to look like and failing to recognize what is already before us, but that's probably an entire article unto itself.

If we do continue down that path, though, it does seem like it would lead to denial. And I have seen many people deny God, and wax proud in their denial. Mind you, I've also met many humble atheists who very reasonably deny the various definitions of God they've encountered. I'm not talking about them, for even Baha'u'llah said, "Whoso claimeth to have known Thee hath, by virtue of such a claim, testified to his own ignorance..." So how can I fault anyone for not believing?

But to wax proud about it? That is a form of egotism that I just don't understand.

Why would that be the "most burning fire"? I'm not sure. Really, I'm not. But I can imagine that being shown proof after proof, and denying every single one of them over and over, would probably lead to frustration, and yes, even anger against those who do believe. And that anger, growing with every new sign that is shown, or every new believer who is satisfied, would, I suppose, be like a burning fire that one cannot escape.

Again, all of this comes down to one's own actions. This fire does not seem to something that is imposed upon us, but rather is the result of our own perspective.


Saturday, November 14, 2026

Words of Wisdom, part 4

Now that Baha'u'llah has told us about magnanimity and wealth, He continues with:

The source of all evil is for man to turn away from his Lord and set his heart on things ungodly.

Again, the source, the origin point, where it all begins.

It seems strange to me, though, because when I think of evil I think of it in terms of an absence of good, just as cold is actually a lesser degree of heat, or darkness an absence of light.

But then, as I think about it while sipping my coffee this morning, I'm reminded of an old experiment we did back when I was in university. The challenge was to try and walk a straight line. No problem. We just  began walking. Then we were asked to close our eyes and continue walking that straight line. Again, no problem. But the challenge came when we were to turn our head. At that point it didn't matter whether our eyes were open or closed, we always, and I mean always, drifted in the direction we were looking.

Now I imagine life as something like a line. If we are walking through our life, striving to develop into more spiritual beings, our attention is likely focused on God. We are probably looking in that direction. And, I guess, the tendency would be to drift in that direction. Seems good to me. But if that line has God at the far end, what's behind us? I would say our more materialistic existence. And if we turn away from God and begin focusing on the more material aspects of life, then it seems to me that we would drift in that direction.

Of course, this doesn't mean that paying attention to our material well-being is necessarily the beginning of evil. We are told in the Writings to work for a living and be conscious of how we use our material resources. That doesn't mean, though, that they have to be the focus of our entire life. We just read two paragraphs about expending our wealth in the path of God. I think this just clarifies it. Don't make the accumulation of those resources our entire focus. In other words, don't turn away from God.

There is another aspect I want to go back to, namely the idea that evil is the absence of good. Baha'u'llah seems to be hinting at something different here. But is He?

Let's go back to the idea of cold being an absence of heat. If you take a piece of iron and out it near a fire, it gets hot. It becomes a source of heat. But as soon as you move it away, all that heat it has stored begins to dissipate. It gradually becomes colder until it is no longer radiates that heat.

I think we're like that piece of iron. Maybe this is why we are supposed to read the Writings every day, pray every day, remember God every single day of our life. It's like keeping the iron near the fire. But when we turn away? Isn't that like removing the iron from the fire? Won't our own inner light and warmth begin to dissipate? Won't we become cold and dark, like that lump of metal? And when our heart becomes cold and dark? I can see how this simple turning away can be the "source of all evil".

And all of this follows so beautifully from the previous passages on magnanimity. When we feel spiritually wealthy, we are more able to give. When we turn away from the source of that wealth, we risk becoming increasingly preoccupied with what we lack.

Oh, and then all of this leads us right into the next passage:

The most burning fire is to question the signs of God, to dispute idly that which He hath revealed, to deny Him and carry one’s self proudly before Him.

But my coffee is cold now, and I have to get back to working on the house. Let's continue this next time.


Friday, November 13, 2026

Words of Wisdom, Part 3

As some of you may know, I recently moved to Montreal. Well, a suburb actually. Ste-Marthe-sur-le-Lac. And one of the difficulties with moving, aside from not knowing where whatever particular item I'm looking for is, (I do know, actually. What I'm looking for is in a box.), is that it interrupted my regular routine of writing.

To try and compensate for that I did my best to write a number of articles ahead of time and put them on a schedule for posting. And that worked great, I think. But those articles ran out the other day. And that's how the previous article about teaching got posted before this one. I meant to finish writing about Words of Wisdom, but the idea got lost in the shuffle. Oh well. I thank you ahead of time for forgiving me.

So let's get back to it, shall we? Ten more paragraphs left, and what a set of ideas they are.

We're currently at:

The beginning of magnanimity is when man expendeth his wealth on himself, on his family and on the poor among his brethren in his Faith.

I find this one interesting because it doesn't talk about the source, or its essence. It talks about where it begins. In fact, the way He phrases it reminds me of a ray in mathematics. There is a starting point and then it continues from there toward infinity.

Miriam-Webster's dictionary defines magnanimity as "the quality of being noble, high-minded, and generously forgiving, especially toward a rival, an enemy, or someone less powerful". This is not quite the same as being generous, but it does overlap. And this qualifier of "especially toward a rival, an enemy" shows that our common understanding goes beyond what Baha'u'llah has actually said here. So I don't think He is describing magnanimity in the sense of a definition, but He is telling us where it starts.

What I find intriguing is that it begins with oneself. From there it expands to one's family. And these are both easy. It is very easy to be generous to yourself, and those that are close to you. Only after that does it further grow to "the poor among one's fellow believers". But that's also an easy step, for these are the people the you regard as similar to yourself. You share a faith. Yet all this is only the beginning of magnanimity. From there it can grow to include those that are different, those that are seemingly alien, to you.

If this is only the beginning of magnanimity, then I suspect its development should eventually take us beyond those boundaries. It should grow to include people who don't share our beliefs, our culture, our assumptions or even our understanding of the world.

I don't think this progression is about becoming less generous to ourselves as we move outward, though. I suspect it's about enlarging the number of people we regard as deserving of the same generosity.

And all of this leads us to the next paragraph:

The essence of wealth is love for Me; whoso loveth Me is the possessor of all things, and he that loveth Me not is indeed of the poor and needy. This is that which the Finger of Glory and Splendor hath revealed.

When speaking of magnanimity, we naturally think of not only generosity, but also the responsible use of our wealth. And this, naturally, requires a better understanding what is truly meant by wealth. Here Baha'u'llah does not allow us to fall into the trap of thinking of wealth in material terms. Here the very essence of wealth is our love for God, or His Manifestation, which, from our perspective, is essentially the same thing.

Now I have to steep back a moment. How does this relate to wealth? For me, wealth is not measured by how much money we have in the bank, but how much choice we have. For example, if I were to go to the grocery store, the food I can purchase is sort of limited by how much money I have. If I only have $10, then I'm not even going to consider looking at the potato chips. If I have $100, then perhaps I might consider a bag. The more money I have, the more I can consider all sorts of other things.

When my preferences are for the simple foods, though, fresh fruit and vegetables, then the amount of money I have has very little bearing on my choices. My sense of wealth, my personal feeling of satisfaction with my resources, increases greatly.

And that is when I feel far more comfortable being generous with those in need. If I felt poor, felt that I didn't have enough to satisfy my own needs, I might be more likely to be stingy.

What I find fascinating about this, though, is that over and over we see the poor giving far greater percentages of their income to charities and those in need. Many of them understand just how little they need to survive, and so when it comes to helping others, they are more ready to rise to the occasion. Yet those with way too much wealth often feel that they don't have enough. And so they tend to be more reluctant in sharing.

Here Baha'u'llah seems to be pointing out that the very essence of wealth, that sense of comfort we may have in feeling that we have enough, is our love for God.  If our happiness depends on having more, there will always be something else we can want. But if our happiness comes from loving God, then our sense of wealth, and satisfaction, can exist independently of how much money we have. It feels like the more we love God, the more content we are with He has given us. And if that isn't the very essence of wealth, then I don't know what is.

I could continue on with the next passage, the "source of all evil", which continues this theme very well, but I have to get to the renovations on the new house for now. And unpacking.

Besides, this gives us a chance to really meditate on these two paragraphs from this amazing tablet. I'd love to hear your thoughts and insights.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

A Thought on Teaching

'Abdu'l-Baha says that the perfect educator must "so educate human minds and thoughts that they may become capable of substantive progress".

I've probably read that line dozens of times, if not more. It is found near the beginning of Some Answered Questions, the third section, entitled "The Need for an Educator", if you're interested. But only last night did it really hit me. And that's the thing about sacred text, isn't it? You can read the same passage over and over and it can impact you in a totally different way every now and then.

The divine educator must "so educate human minds and thoughts that they may become capable of substantive progress".

"Capable".

Think about what that word implies. To me, and of course it's only my own opinion, nothing official, that means that before this the mind is not "capable of substantive progress". Progress, sure, but not "substantive progress".

But what does all of this have to do with me? How does it affect my life? Or my teaching work?

Again, to me, I have to go back to what I've been learning in both the Kitab-i-Iqan and the Epistle to the Son of the Wolf. In both of these volumes Baha'u'llah doesn't just answer a question or two. He doesn't simply share information. In both He works with the individual where they are and takes profound steps to help them become capable of hearing what He has to say.

In terms of the Iqan, the very questions that the uncle of the Bab asked demonstrate that he was not yet ready to hear the answers to his questions. One of them, for example, essentially asks why the Bab did not fulfill the prophecies of old, especially the claim that the promised One would be a sovereign of the world. But when you consider it, one could say that it was the wrong question. The question should not have been "Why didn't He fulfill these things", but rather, "How did He fulfill these things".

The first question implies that He didn't do it, and sort of ends there.

The second leaves open the possibility that He did, and that we just don't see it.

If we are stuck in the first question, then it really doesn't matter what else Baha'u'llah talks about in the book. We won't be in a position to hear it. But when we open ourselves to the possibility of the second question, then we allow ourselves the room for our understanding to grow.

When it comes to the Epistle to the Son of the Wolf, the recipient didn't ask any questions. The Son of the Wolf was an avowed enemy of the Faith who persecuted countless individuals. So what's happening there?

As usual, I don't really know, but it seems to me that Baha'u'llah has to start from a different place than He did with the uncle of the Bab, mainly because the Son of the Wolf is in a different place spiritually. I had long wondered why that book, the Epistle, started with those long passages that basically tell him to get on his knees and beg forgiveness. It didn't seem all that conducive to opening up his heart to the message.

But on reflection, and especially in light of this passage from 'Abdu'l-Baha, it seems that he might have had to do this in order to even be open to the possibility of hearing the message from Baha'u'llah. Without this time of self-reflection, how would he ever have been able to open himself up enough to hear these new words?

Only after such an inner journey does it seem possible for him to begin to recognize the new truths that were being laid bare before him. Perhaps he first needed to look honestly at his own actions and attitudes before he could consider the possibility that those he had condemned might actually have something to teach him. The parallels Baha'u'llah draws between the attacks of earlier religions and those being levelled against Him in His own day must have been difficult for him to recognize. After all, it is one thing to see the faults in others, but quite another to recognize those same faults in ourselves.

And perhaps this is where the difference lies between simply giving someone information and actually teaching them. I can explain something to someone, and they might even understand the words I'm using, but that doesn't necessarily mean they are ready to appreciate what those words mean. Sometimes the difficulty isn't the information itself, but the way we're approaching it. We may need to ask a different question, or look at something from another direction, before we can really begin to understand it.

All this makes me think about my own teaching work. How often do I concentrate on getting the information across, rather than helping someone develop the ability to think about it for themselves? If I'm teaching a child, for example, is my goal simply to have them remember an answer, or is it to help them become curious enough to want to explore the question further? I know from experience that those are not the same.

Then there are the other questions this raises for me. Are there times when giving someone more information is actually less helpful than asking a question that helps them to examine their assumptions? How much of teaching involves recognising where someone is starting from, rather than simply deciding where we want them to end up? And just how closely do we need to listen to their questions, and pay attention to their body language, in order to better understand where they are at the moment?

I believe it is very important to recognize that helping someone become capable of understanding something doesn't mean manipulating them into accepting our conclusions. It means helping them develop the capacity to investigate, reflect and reach a more considered understanding for themselves. A teacher can create opportunities for understanding, but they cannot simply bestow understanding on another person. The person still has to do something with what is offered. It is, in the end, up to them.

This also might explain the different reactions the recipients had to the Iqan and the Epistle. The two men were in very different places to begin with, and their responses to what Baha'u'llah wrote were quite different too. It makes me wonder how much of that had to do with their own willingness to examine what was being offered to them.

And perhaps that's what 'Abdu'l-Baha is getting at when He uses the word "capable". Maybe the measure of good teaching isn't how much information we manage to convey, but how much more capable the other person becomes of discovering things for themselves, for that is probably where "substantive progress" occurs.